Shai Gilgeous-Alexander

[Brad Stevens]

Current Rating - 89
Suggested Rating - 92


O Aware - 90 (4.9 O RAPTOR)
FG - 96 (31.4ppg, 46.4% Mid Range FG%, 5.6 MidRange FGM/g)
3PT - 59 (34.9 3P%, 0.9 3PM/g)
FT - 90
Ins Score - 80 (67.7% 0-3ft FG%, 3.9 0-3ft FGM/g)
Pass - 49 (4.3 Assists/36 - Bad Pass TO/36)
Handle - 76 (370.0 Dribbles/Lost Ball TO, 380.4 Dribbles/36)
D Aware - 75 (0.1 D RAPTOR)
Steal - 82 (2.2 Steal %, 1.7 Steals/g)
Block - 55 (2.6 Block%, 1.0 Blocks/g)
O Reb - 26 (2.6 Oreb%, 0.9 O Reb/g)
D Reb - 50 (12.1 D Reb%, 3.9 D Reb/g)
Speed - 92 (2k Speed translated)
Quick - 87 (2k Perimeter Defense translated)
Jump - 83 (2k Vertical translated)
Strong - 75 (2k Interior Defense translated)
Fatigue - 97 (2k Stamina translated)

[Jerry West]

91

[Brian Scalabrine]

91

[Jared Montini]

91

[George Gervin]

92

[Amare Stoudemire]

91

[Steve Nash]

91

[Arvydas Sabonis]

91

[Mark Price]

91.5

But I don't know how SGA is a 91 or 92 when Booker is a 90 and both Mitchell and Brown are 88s. They all feel pretty close, but how they're currently stacking up probably isn't how I would do it. But, it just feels a little jumbled with the high 80s low 90s players. Probably a conversation for a different time though.

[Kareem Abdul-Jabbar]

91

[Walt Frazier]

91

[Tom Izzo]

I'm not taking SGA over DeRozan but it's wild to me you had people voting 84-86 for DeMar and 91-92 for Shai. Similar 3 point ratings, similar FG %. Similar stats except SGA puts up 5 more PPG. Similar team record.

I'm also unsure how SGA is better than Mitchell, Booker, and others as Price pointed out. SGA is a stellar player and exciting because of what he's doing today coupled with his potential but how do we rate him over veterans who are doing similar things today with history of success?

(And before the discord mafia twists my words, I'm not saying SGA isn't > DeRozan right now, but for the people who voted 85/86 for DeRozan but then 91-92 for SGA? That's a huge discrepancy that isn't fair in my opinion. However, I do think there are cases that Donovan Mitchell > SGA.)

[Ian Noble]

Dude's not even got past the first round of the playoffs yet, and hasn't even qualified for the playoffs whilst playing as the #1 option

90

[George Gervin]

Bump above Mar 27 SW Closures for more votes

[George Gervin]

THREAD CLOSED.

New Rating = 91 (91.2)